News and Archives of Jacques Delors
News & Archives from
Jacques Delors
Support the Jacques Delors Institute!
Click here
Subscribe to our newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter
Read our newsletter
Katrin Auel

Katrin Auel

Lecturer in Politics, a Fellow at Mansfield College, University of Oxford and visiting fellow at the ...
Julio Baquero Cruz

Julio Baquero Cruz

Member of the Legal Service of the European Commission since March 2009. He is also visiting ...
Themes :
Select ...
Choose a theme
Types :
Select ...
Choose type
Dates :
Select ...
European Union and Citizens

Karlsruhe's Europe

on July 27, 2010, 14:58
Studies and reports - Katrin Auel and Julio Baquero Cruz

When on June 30th 2009, the German Constitutional court delivered its rulingon the Lisbon Treaty, it met with mixed feelings. On the one hand, by recognisingthe compatibility of the Treaty with the Basic law, it made possible its ratificationby the German President, thereby removing one of the last stumbling blocks onthe rocky road to its eventual coming into force.

On the other hand, the detailedanalysis of European Union it contained was widely perceived as a hostile signalby most readers.Unlike its 1993 forerunner on the Maastricht Treaty, this ruling did not limit itselfto signalling a degree of discontent with the current scope and pace of the inte-gration process, but clearly erected barriers to further integration, by demandinga closer parliamentary scrutiny of decisions taken in Brussels and by threateningto oppose the implementation in Germany of EU rules that would violate the sub-sidiarity principle. In other words, the objections it raised were more than rhetori-cal: they aimed at exerting pressure on the federal government.

One year on, it seems clear that this ruling will have a lasting impact on Germany’sEuropean policy. In the discussion on the assistance package to Greece, for instance, opponents to a German participation in the stabilisation effort decidedto bring the matter before the Constitutional court. But the latter’s influence willalso be felt beyond the German borders. The weight of Germany and the prestigeof its institutions are such that the Court’s concerns are likely to find an echo inother countries, all the more so because the intergovernmental view of Europethat it promotes resonates with the current mood and practice.

Hence the need toanalyse in detail the implications of this ruling, not only for Germany, but for therest of Europe as well. This is the ambition of this study, which will focus on twoissues of central importance: the impact of the ruling on the authority of EU law,and the role of national parliaments.
Contact - Sitemap - Legal - Vacancies
Jacques Delors Institute - 19, rue de Milan - 75009 Paris - Tel. +33 1 44 58 97 97 - Email:
Jacques Delors Institut – Berlin, Pariser Platz 6, 10117 Berlin
Powered by Walabiz
We use cookies on our website.
If you continue to use our website you consent to the use of cookies.